How to fix bank feed error "Select the account this money transfers to"?

I created a new credit card account. Quickbooks does not support importing to the bank feed from this credit card, so I will need to be manually inputting. From my bank account bank feed, I select "Record as transfer" and the new credit card account to record the payment that my bank account made to pay off my credit card. I cannot add this and I am getting the error message from Quickbooks "Select the account this money transfers to". The error doesn't really make sense because it is selected. Any suggestions?